Article

10 ways the ‘reset’ leaves Britons worse off

The government is presenting the outcome of the latest UK-EU summit as a ‘win’ for Britain that will lower the cost of living, make business easier, and increase opportunities for young people. In reality it will do none of those things.

Here are ten ways that the ‘reset’ will leave Britons worse off…

More costs for farms and food businesses

1. The agri-food deal (to align Sanitary and Phytosanitary rules) will impose additional costs and regulations on every farm and food business, even those that do not export to the EU, more than offsetting any benefits for the small number that do.

Britain has never been a major exporter of food and never will be. In any event, exporting more food to the EU will not reduce prices at home.

Loss of control of food and animal welfare standards

2. The agri-food deal will require us to follow EU rules with no real say in how they are determined. This means that our food and animal welfare standards will be decided in Brussels, not Westminster, reversing most if not all of the improvements made since Brexit.

Any remaining parliamentary scrutiny will inevitably suffer given the large volumes of EU law that will fall within the scope of the agreements.

Underming our post-Brexit trade freedoms

3. The UK already had the ability to reduce barriers to allow cheaper imports of food (and other goods) both from the EU and, thanks to Brexit, from the rest of the world. Those freedoms will be lost if we have to realign with EU rules and tariffs.

The UK government has failed to address the implications for our new post-Brexit trade deals, including the ambitious Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP).

Removing vital safety checks

4. Removing safety checks on food imports from the EU could also increase our exposure to the many animal diseases which are far more common in continental Europe, including foot-and-mouth disease and African Swine Fever.

Higher energy costs

5. Linking the UK’s Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) to the EU’s ETS and aligning the UK’s proposed Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) with the EU version will increase the cost of living. This is both because the EU ETS’s emission charges are higher and because the CBAM will increase the cost of energy-intensive imports.

An unbalanced youth mobility scheme

6. The UK-EU ‘Youth Experience Scheme’ (YES) will be unbalanced, with many more EU citizens coming to work or study in the UK than head in the other direction. Indeed, the Treasury’s claim that the YES will boost GDP by 0.22% explicitly relies on an increase in net immigration to the UK at a time when there is already a crisis in youth unemployment. Adjusting for this, even the Treasury admits that there will be no gain in GDP per head.

Moreover, the EU has actually stopped the UK from agreeing more favourable bilateral schemes with several EU member states, notably France, Germany and Spain.

A bill to lower tuition fees for EU students

7. As part of the reset, the UK has committed to conclude negotiations within six months on a ‘supplementary agreement’ on tuition fees for EU students. This will inevitably result in lower fees, imposing an additional financial burden on cash-strapped UK universities which will have to be covered by the UK taxpayer.

The only uncertainty is how big that bill will be, but Russell Group analysis has shown granting home tuition fee status for EU students could cost UK universities £570 million.

Still no clarity on 'Made in Europe'

8. The agreement leaves several major issues unresolved, prolonging the uncertainty for businesses and investors. These include whether the UK will take part in the EU’s protectionist ‘Made in Europe’ scheme and in the EU’s internal electricity market, both of which would pose significant economic, financial, legal, and political challenges.

The latest statement also built on two changes agreed at the first ‘reset’ Summit in 2025.

Lost control over fisheries

9. The earlier agreement to extend the existing deal on fishing rights until 2038 has locked in the disappointingly small reduction in the EU’s catch share in UK waters. It will still not allow the UK to regain control of its fisheries – a red line for other countries, notably Norway and Iceland.

Turing was far better than Erasmus

10. The earlier agreement to replace the UK's tailored Turing student exchange scheme with a return to Erasmus will limit opportunities for British students to study elsewhere in the world, as well as require the UK to pay extra to subsidise EU participants.

The verdict?

In short, the decision to reopen the Brexit debate is already draining political capital and energy that should go towards solving the UK’s real economic problems – and for what? Rarely has so much control been surrendered for so little.

Britain Unbound Team
Britain Unbound Team