Both the EU Withdrawal Arrangements Bill and the European Partnership (as defined by the King’s Speech Notes) are a response to exactly the same challenge, the fact that the Brexit Referendum has never been honoured because part of the UK has always remained effectively in the EU. However, the solutions that they propose for the purpose of addressing the resulting difficulties represent the opposite of each other.
The Government’s EU Partnership Bill solution is to ‘dynamically align’ with EU law. For example, on plant and animal health, it is expected that the European Partnership Bill will result in Great Britain dynamically aligning with the same 130+ EU SPS laws to which NI is already subject. The European Partnership Bill solution, therefore, is to manage the border problem by bringing Great Britain into alignment with Northern Ireland, extending EU colony status from Northern Ireland to the rest of the country.
By contrast, the solution proposed by the European Withdrawal Arrangements Bill, which I first introduced to Parliament in the last session, and which is now sponsored by Lord Dodds, resolves the presenting difficulty by terminating Northern Ireland’s status as an EU colony, bringing it into line with Great Britain, delivering Brexit to the whole UK.
As such the Withdrawal Arrangements Bill moves the customs and SPS border between the UK and the Republic of Ireland from the Irish Sea to the UK-ROI land border. It thereby restores the territorial integrity of the UK and ends the humiliation by which 1.9 million UK citizens have been disenfranchised in 300 areas of law.
Crucially, while the Belfast Good Friday Agreement does not require it, the Bill also makes provision for the UK-ROI land border, which already operates economically as a tax and currency border, to operate as a customs and SPS border without marking the border with customs posts or any hard infrastructure.
It rises to this challenge by means of the deployment of a mixture of the technological and administrative solutions known as Alternative Arrangements in the context of the critical legal mechanisms provided by Mutual Enforcement.