Article

The Real Significance of 20 November

This week Government policy reached an unprecedented level of incoherence.

On Monday night the Prime Minister argued that the existence of a trade border between the UK and the EU across the English Channel constitutes an intolerable burden that must be removed.

However, on Tuesday afternoon, the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland rejected an application by MLAs to block the application of the new customs border which denies Northern Ireland unfettered access to inputs and goods from the greater part of our home economy, suggesting that this is perfectly acceptable.

How can having one kind of trade border (an SPS border) separating ourselves from foreign countries be a huge problem, when having another kind of trade border (a customs border) dividing ourselves in two is fine?

Unprecedented Incoherence

This level of incoherence is unprecedented and speaks not simply to an economic crisis but to a constitutional crisis of immense proportions.

We are being led by a government that is clearly not here for us but is rather beholden to international interests whose purposes do not come into any kind of meaningful focus when viewed through the lens of the UK and the UK national interest.

As such the extraordinary and bizarre dislocation between different aspects of government policy, which only make sense when viewed in the context of the lens of the ‘EU national interest’, serve as a wake-up call to the nation if we can hear it.

I believe that the way forward our country now desperately needs is that provided by the European Withdrawal Arrangements Bill which is to have its Second Reading debate in the House of Lords tomorrow.

The timing could not be better because the Prime Minister has indicated that next week will see the publication of his chosen legislation vehicle for undermining Brexit, the European Partnership Bill. It means not only that on the day of the EU Reset Summit in Brussels, a Brexit alternative will be set out in Parliament, but that Parliament will get to debate it before the Government’s European Partnership Bill.

In that sense what is said will be of real interest in the Commons, assuming that is where the Government’s Bill begins its journey.

The Withdrawal Arrangements Bill

Both the EU Withdrawal Arrangements Bill and the European Partnership (as defined by the King’s Speech Notes) are a response to exactly the same challenge, the fact that the Brexit Referendum has never been honoured because part of the UK has always remained effectively in the EU. However, the solutions that they propose for the purpose of addressing the resulting difficulties represent the opposite of each other.

The Government’s EU Partnership Bill solution is to ‘dynamically align’ with EU law. For example, on plant and animal health, it is expected that the European Partnership Bill will result in Great Britain dynamically aligning with the same 130+ EU SPS laws to which NI is already subject. The European Partnership Bill solution, therefore, is to manage the border problem by bringing Great Britain into alignment with Northern Ireland, extending EU colony status from Northern Ireland to the rest of the country.

By contrast, the solution proposed by the European Withdrawal Arrangements Bill, which I first introduced to Parliament in the last session, and which is now sponsored by Lord Dodds, resolves the presenting difficulty by terminating Northern Ireland’s status as an EU colony, bringing it into line with Great Britain, delivering Brexit to the whole UK.

As such the Withdrawal Arrangements Bill moves the customs and SPS border between the UK and the Republic of Ireland from the Irish Sea to the UK-ROI land border. It thereby restores the territorial integrity of the UK and ends the humiliation by which 1.9 million UK citizens have been disenfranchised in 300 areas of law.

Crucially, while the Belfast Good Friday Agreement does not require it, the Bill also makes provision for the UK-ROI land border, which already operates economically as a tax and currency border, to operate as a customs and SPS border without marking the border with customs posts or any hard infrastructure.

It rises to this challenge by means of the deployment of a mixture of the technological and administrative solutions known as Alternative Arrangements in the context of the critical legal mechanisms provided by Mutual Enforcement.

In Conclusion

Unless and until the whole UK leaves the EU, we will be the subject of constant EU manipulation and the reality of Brexit will always remain elusive.

Now more than ever, as we confront the EU Reset proposals, we are forced to face up to the fact that it really is time to ‘get Brexit done’, which means the whole country must finally leave the EU.

Jim Allister KC MP
Jim Allister KC MP

Jim Allister KC MP is the Member of Parliament for North Antrim and the leader of the TUV (Traditional Unionist Voice) Party. He served as a Member of the Northern Ireland Assembly from 20011 until 2024 and as a Member of the European Parliament from 2004 until 2009. In addition to politics, Jim was called to the Bar of Northern Ireland as a barrister in 1976, specialising in criminal law. In 2001, he was made a QC. Jim and the TUV have consistently opposed the Irish Sea Border. In the last session he introduced the European Union Withdrawal Arrangements Bill which ends the EU’s partitioning of the UK, while protecting the integrity of the UK and EU Internal Markets through Mutual Enforcement which avoids the need for a hard border across the island of Ireland.